Journal of Ultrafine Grained and Nanostructured Materials

Journal of Ultrafine Grained and Nanostructured Materials

Processing of Ultrafine/nano-grained microstructures through additive manufacturing techniques: a critical review

Document Type : Review Paper

Authors
Javad Gholamzadeh 1
Seyed Mahmood Fatemi 2
nafiseh mollaei 3
Amir Abedi 4
1 shahid Rajaee University
2 Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University
3 iran uni of Science and Technology
4 Shahid Rajaee University
10.22059/jufgnsm.2024.02.10
Abstract
Additive manufacturing (AM) has emerged as a transformative technology that produces complex, high-performance components, enabling unprecedented design flexibility and material efficiency. This paper explores the potential of additive manufacturing processes to produce ultrafine/nano-grained microstructures, which are characterized by superior mechanical properties, enhanced corrosion resistance, and improved thermal stability. The study delves into various AM techniques based on the physical phenomenon incorporated to additively bond the material portions. Accordingly, the reported results in the literature were reviewed by categorizing the methods into melting-based and deformation-based approaches and examining the conditions and parameters critical to achieving ultrafine/nano-grained microstructures. Key factors, including the optimization of process parameters as well as the specification of initial feedstock material, are discussed. This comprehensive review shows that in melting-based methods, lower power and higher scan speed result in reduced heat input, leading to smaller melt pools and faster solidification rates, which in turn produce finer grains. On the other hand, in deformation-based methods, smaller initial particle sizes and higher particle velocities generate greater impact energy, which can lead to grain size reduction. This review article also highlights the current potential and achievements in the field of additive manufacturing for producing ultrafine/nano-grained materials, which may contribute to the development of high-performance materials and components for the next generation.
Keywords
Additive manufacturing
Ultrafine/nano-grained
Grain refinement
Melting based method
Deformation based method

  1. References

    1. Bhatia A, Sehgal AK. Additive manufacturing materials, methods and applications: A review. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2023;81:1060-7.
    2. Mukherjee T, Elmer J, Wei H, Lienert T, Zhang W, Kou S, et al. Control of grain structure, phases, and defects in additive manufacturing of high-performance metallic components. Progress in Materials Science. 2023:101153.
    3. Schimbäck D, Mair P, Bärtl M, Palm F, Leichtfried G, Mayer S, et al. Alloy design strategy for microstructural-tailored scandium-modified aluminium alloys for additive manufacturing. Scripta Materialia. 2022;207:114277.
    4. Han Q, Gu Y, Huang J, Wang L, Low KW, Feng Q, et al. Selective laser melting of Hastelloy X nanocomposite: effects of TiC reinforcement on crack elimination and strength improvement. Composites Part B: Engineering. 2020;202:108442.
    5. Haghdadi N, Ledermueller C, Chen H, Chen Z, Liu Q, Li X, et al. Evolution of microstructure and mechanical properties in 2205 duplex stainless steels during additive manufacturing and heat treatment. Materials Science and Engineering: A. 2022;835:142695.
    6. Carvalho AP, Figueiredo RB. An overview of the effect of grain size on mechanical properties of magnesium and its alloys. Materials Transactions. 2023;64(7):1272-83.
    7. Figueiredo RB, Kawasaki M, Langdon TG. The role of grain size in achieving excellent properties in structural materials. Journal of Materials Research and Technology. 2024;30:3448-62.
    8. Tan JL, Tang C, Wong CH. A computational study on porosity evolution in parts produced by selective laser melting. Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A. 2018;49:3663-73.
    9. Dilip J, Zhang S, Teng C, Zeng K, Robinson C, Pal D, et al. Influence of processing parameters on the evolution of melt pool, porosity, and microstructures in Ti-6Al-4V alloy parts fabricated by selective laser melting. Progress in Additive Manufacturing. 2017;2:157-67.
    10. Dass A, Moridi A. State of the art in directed energy deposition: From additive manufacturing to materials design. Coatings. 2019;9(7):418.
    11. Dev Singh D, Mahender T, Raji Reddy A. Powder bed fusion process: A brief review. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2021;46:350-5.
    12. Shen LD, Huang Y, Tian ZJ, Hua GR. Direct fabrication of bulk nanostructured ceramic from nano-Al2O3 powders by selective laser sintering. Key Engineering Materials. 2007;329:613-8.
    13. Zhao Y, Bian H, Wang H, Kenta A, Kenta Y, Chiba A. Non-equilibrium solidification behavior associated with powder characteristics during electron beam additive manufacturing. Materials & Design. 2022;221:110915.
    14. Li B, Qian B, Xu Y, Liu Z, Zhang J, Xuan F. Additive manufacturing of ultrafine-grained austenitic stainless steel matrix composite via vanadium carbide reinforcement addition and selective laser melting: Formation mechanism and strengthening effect. Materials Science and Engineering: A. 2019;745:495-508.
    15. Zhou Y, Ning F, Zhang P, Sharma A. Geometrical, microstructural, and mechanical properties of curved-surface AlSi10Mg parts fabricated by powder bed fusion additive manufacturing. Materials & Design. 2021;198:109360.
    16. Talebi M, Razaghian A, Saboori A, Niroumand B. Effects of Cu addition and heat treatment on the microstructure and hardness of pure Ti prepared by Selective laser melting (SLM). Journal of Ultrafine Grained and Nanostructured Materials. 2023;56(2):213-23.
    17. Gu D, Zhang H, Dai D, Xia M, Hong C, Poprawe R. Laser additive manufacturing of nano-TiC reinforced Ni-based nanocomposites with tailored microstructure and performance. Composites Part B: Engineering. 2019;163:585-97.
    18. Mosallanejad MH, Niroumand B, Ghibaudo C, Biamino S, Salmi A, Fino P, et al. In-situ alloying of a fine grained fully equiaxed Ti-based alloy via electron beam powder bed fusion additive manufacturing process. Additive Manufacturing. 2022;56:102878.
    19. Wang X, Zhang L-J, Ning J, Li S, Zhang L-L, Long J, et al. Fe element promotes the transformation from columnar to equiaxed grains and the formation of ultrafine microstructure of Ti-6Al-4V alloy by laser wire deposition. Additive Manufacturing. 2021;48:102442.
    20. Yang M, Wang L, Yan W. Phase-field modeling of grain evolution in additive manufacturing with addition of reinforcing particles. Additive Manufacturing. 2021;47:102286.
    21. Fereiduni E, Ghasemi A, Elbestawi M. TiB reinforced Ti-6Al-4V matrix composites with improved short-term creep performance fabricated by laser powder bed fusion. Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 2021;70:593-607.
    22. Zhang D, Prasad A, Bermingham MJ, Todaro CJ, Benoit MJ, Patel MN, et al. Grain refinement of alloys in fusion-based additive manufacturing processes. Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A. 2020;51:4341-59.
    23. R. Kaschel F, Celikin M, Dowling DP. Effects of laser power on geometry, microstructure and mechanical properties of printed Ti-6Al-4V parts. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 2020;278:116539.
    24. Xiong F, Huang C, Kafka OL, Lian Y, Yan W, Chen M, et al. Grain growth prediction in selective electron beam melting of Ti-6Al-4V with a cellular automaton method. Materials & Design. 2021;199:109410.
    25. Choo H, Sham K-L, Bohling J, Ngo A, Xiao X, Ren Y, et al. Effect of laser power on defect, texture, and microstructure of a laser powder bed fusion processed 316L stainless steel. Materials & Design. 2019;164:107534.
    26. Agarwal N, Monu MCC, Tamil Selvam K, Obeidi MA, Brabazon D. Study of the effects of laser power and scanning speed on the microstructural morphologies and physical properties of L-PBF produced Ni52.39Ti47.61. Journal of Materials Research and Technology. 2023;27:8334-43.
    27. Hu Z, Ma Z, Yu L, Liu Y. Functionally graded materials with grain-size gradients and heterogeneous microstructures achieved by additive manufacturing. Scripta Materialia. 2023;226:115197.
    28. Spierings AB, Dawson K, Uggowitzer PJ, Wegener K. Influence of SLM scan-speed on microstructure, precipitation of Al3Sc particles and mechanical properties in Sc-and Zr-modified Al-Mg alloys. Materials & Design. 2018;140:134-43.
    29. Zinovieva O, Romanova V, Balokhonov R, editors. Effect of hatch distance on the microstructure of additively manufactured 316 L steel. AIP Conference Proceedings; 2020: AIP Publishing.
    30. Ehsan Saghaian S, Nematollahi M, Toker G, Hinojos A, Shayesteh Moghaddam N, Saedi S, et al. Effect of hatch spacing and laser power on microstructure, texture, and thermomechanical properties of laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) additively manufactured NiTi. Optics & Laser Technology. 2022;149:107680.
    31. Li Y, Song L, Xie P, Cheng M, Xiao H. Enhancing hardness and wear performance of laser additive manufactured Ti6Al4V alloy through achieving ultrafine microstructure. Materials. 2020;13(5):1210.
    32. Abdelmoula M, Musinski W. Predicting and correlating melt pool characteristics with processing parameters in IN625 powder bed fusion additive manufacturing. Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 2024;121:427-45.
    33. Qi Y, Zhang H, Yang X, Wang Y, Han C, Fan W, et al. Achieving superior high-temperature mechanical properties in Al-Cu-Li-Sc-Zr alloy with nano-scale microstructure via laser additive manufacturing. Materials Research Letters. 2024;12(1):17-25.
    34. Hyer HC, Petrie CM. Effect of powder layer thickness on the microstructural development of additively manufactured SS316. Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 2022;76:666-74.
    35. Zafari A, Xia K. Nano/ultrafine grained immiscible Fe-Cu alloy with ultrahigh strength produced by selective laser melting. Materials Research Letters. 2021;9(6):247-54.
    36. Weaver JS, Heigel JC, Lane BM. Laser spot size and scaling laws for laser beam additive manufacturing. Journal of Manufacturing Processes. 2022;73:26-39.
    37. Li B, Qian B, Xu Y, Liu Z, Xuan F. Fine-structured CoCrFeNiMn high-entropy alloy matrix composite with 12 wt% TiN particle reinforcements via selective laser melting assisted additive manufacturing. Materials letters. 2019;252:88-91.
    38. Kok Y, Tan XP, Wang P, Nai M, Loh NH, Liu E, et al. Anisotropy and heterogeneity of microstructure and mechanical properties in metal additive manufacturing: A critical review. Materials & Design. 2018;139:565-86.
    39. Simonelli M, Zou Z, Barriobero-Vila P, Tse YY. The development of ultrafine grain structure in an additively manufactured titanium alloy via high-temperature microscopy. Materialia. 2023;30:101856.
    40. Hu Z, Gao S, Mikula J, Shen X, Seet HL, Quek SS, et al. Enhanced Plastic Stability: Achieving High Performance in a Al6xxx Alloy Fabricated by Additive Manufacturing. Advanced Materials. 2024:2307825.
    41. Zhang D, Qiu D, Gibson MA, Zheng Y, Fraser HL, StJohn DH, et al. Additive manufacturing of ultrafine-grained high-strength titanium alloys. Nature. 2019;576(7785):91-5.
    42. Zhang F, Gao P, Tan H, Li Y, Chen Y, Mei M, et al. Tailoring grain morphology in Ti-6Al-3Mo through heterogeneous nucleation in directed energy deposition. Journal of Materials Science & Technology. 2021;88:132-42.
    43. Lu B, Cui X, Ma W, Dong M, Fang Y, Wen X, et al. Promoting the heterogeneous nucleation and the functional properties of directed energy deposited NiTi alloy by addition of La2O3. Additive Manufacturing. 2020;33:101150.
    44. Chao Q, Mateti S, Annasamy M, Imran M, Joseph J, Cai Q, et al. Nanoparticle-mediated ultra grain refinement and reinforcement in additively manufactured titanium alloys. Additive Manufacturing. 2021;46:102173.
    45. Wang X, Zhang L-J, Ning J, Li S, Zhang L-L, Long J. Hierarchical grain refinement during the laser additive manufacturing of Ti-6Al-4V alloys by the addition of micron-sized refractory particles. Additive Manufacturing. 2021;45:102045.
    46. Yuan T, Ren X, Chen S, Jiang X. Grain refinement and property improvements of Al–Zn–Mg–Cu alloy by heterogeneous particle addition during wire and arc additive manufacturing. Journal of Materials Research and Technology. 2022;16:824-39.
    47. Alhuzaim A, Imbrogno S, Attallah MM. Controlling microstructural and mechanical properties of direct laser deposited Inconel 718 via laser power. Journal of Alloys and Compounds. 2021;872:159588.
    48. Yao XX, Ge P, Li JY, Wang YF, Li T, Liu WW, et al. Controlling the solidification process parameters of direct energy deposition additive manufacturing considering laser and powder properties. Computational Materials Science. 2020;182:109788.
    49. Lee CH, Narayana P, Choi S-W, Reddy N, Kim JH, Kang N, et al. Influence of Direct Energy Deposition Parameters on Ti–6Al–4V Component’s Structure-Property Homogeneity. Metals. 2021;11(6):887.
    50. Narayana PL, Kim JH, Lee J, Choi S-W, Lee S, Park CH, et al. Optimization of process parameters for direct energy deposited Ti-6Al-4V alloy using neural networks. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. 2021;114(11):3269-83.
    51. Lin T-C, Cao C, Sokoluk M, Jiang L, Wang X, Schoenung JM, et al. Aluminum with dispersed nanoparticles by laser additive manufacturing. Nature communications. 2019;10(1):4124.
    52. Chen H, Ye L, Han Y, Chen C, Fan J. Additive manufacturing of W–Fe composites using laser metal deposition: Microstructure, phase transformation, and mechanical properties. Materials Science and Engineering: A. 2021;811:141036.
    53. Hong C, Gu D, Dai D, Alkhayat M, Urban W, Yuan P, et al. Laser additive manufacturing of ultrafine TiC particle reinforced Inconel 625 based composite parts: Tailored microstructures and enhanced performance. Materials Science and Engineering: A. 2015;635:118-28.
    54. Henriques ABB, de Aguiar PL, dos Santos RG, Miagava J, editors. Evaluation of Process Parameters Modifications on Directed Energy Deposition Manufactured Parts Obtained in a Hybrid Additive Manufacturing Machine. International Manufacturing Science and Engineering Conference; 2022: American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
    55. Chai R, Zhang Y, Zhong B, Zhang C. Effect of scan speed on grain and microstructural morphology for laser additive manufacturing of 304 stainless steel. Reviews on Advanced Materials Science. 2021;60(1):744-60.
    56. Zhang P-l, Jia Z-y, Yan H, Yu Z-s, Wu D, Shi H-c, et al. Effect of deposition rate on microstructure and mechanical properties of wire arc additive manufacturing of Ti-6Al-4V components. Journal of Central South University. 2021;28(4):1100-10.
    57. Valarezo A, Shinoda K, Sampath S. Effect of deposition rate and deposition temperature on residual stress of HVOF-sprayed coatings. Journal of Thermal Spray Technology. 2020;29:1322-38.
    58. Soylemez E. High deposition rate approach of selective laser melting through defocused single bead experiments and thermal finite element analysis for Ti-6Al-4V. Additive Manufacturing. 2020;31:100984.
    59. Hassan A, Pedapati SR, Awang M, Soomro IA. A comprehensive review of friction stir additive manufacturing (FSAM) of non-ferrous alloys. Materials. 2023;16(7):2723.
    60. Zhong C, Biermann T, Gasser A, Poprawe R. Experimental study of effects of main process parameters on porosity, track geometry, deposition rate, and powder efficiency for high deposition rate laser metal deposition. Journal of Laser Applications. 2015;27(4).
    61. Qi X, Liang X, Wang J, Zhang H, Wang X, Liu Z. Microstructure tailoring in laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF): Strategies, challenges, and future outlooks. Journal of Alloys and Compounds. 2024;970:172564.
    62. Todaro C, Easton M, Qiu D, Brandt M, StJohn D, Qian M. Grain refinement of stainless steel in ultrasound-assisted additive manufacturing. Additive Manufacturing. 2021;37:101632.
    63. Geng Y, Panchenko I, Chen X, Ivanov Y, Konovalov S. Wire arc additive manufacturing Al-5.0 Mg alloy: Microstructures and phase composition. Materials Characterization. 2022;187:111875.
    64. Zou Y. Cold spray additive manufacturing: microstructure evolution and bonding features. Accounts of Materials Research. 2021;2(11):1071-81.
    65. Wu B-l, Peng Y-c, Tang H-q, Meng C-c, Zhong Y-f, Zhang F-l, et al. Improving grain structure and dispersoid distribution of nanodiamond reinforced AA6061 matrix composite coatings via high-speed additive friction stir deposition. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 2023;317:117983.
    66. Yu HZ, Mishra RS. Additive friction stir deposition: a deformation processing route to metal additive manufacturing. Materials Research Letters. 2021;9(2):71-83.
    67. Liu M, Wang B, An X, Xue P, Liu F, Wu L, et al. Friction stir additive manufacturing enabling scale-up of ultrafine-grained pure copper with superior mechanical properties. Materials Science and Engineering: A. 2022;857:144088.
    68. Shao C, Li H, Zhu Y, Li P, Yu H, Zhang Z, et al. Nano-additive manufacturing of multilevel strengthened aluminum matrix composites. International Journal of Extreme Manufacturing. 2022;5(1):015102.
    69. Huang F, Tao N. Effects of strain rate and deformation temperature on microstructures and hardness in plastically deformed pure aluminum. Journal of Materials Science & Technology. 2011;27(1):1-7.
    70. Guo-Zheng Q, Yang W, Ying-Ying L, Jie Z. Effect of temperatures and strain rates on the average size of grains refined by dynamic recrystallization for as-extruded 42CrMo steel. Materials Research. 2013;16:1092-105.
    71. Elyasi M, Khoram D, Aghajani Derazkola H, Mirnia MJ. Effects of process parameters on properties of friction stir additive manufactured copper. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. 2023;127(11-12):5651-64.
    72. Chen C, Xie Y, Yin S, Li W, Luo X, Xie X, et al. Ductile and high strength Cu fabricated by solid-state cold spray additive manufacturing. Journal of Materials Science & Technology. 2023;134:234-43.
    73. Xie X, Ma Y, Chen C, Ji G, Verdy C, Wu H, et al. Cold spray additive manufacturing of metal matrix composites (MMCs) using a novel nano-TiB2-reinforced 7075Al powder. Journal of alloys and compounds. 2020;819:152962.
    74. Prashar G, Vasudev H. A comprehensive review on sustainable cold spray additive manufacturing: State of the art, challenges and future challenges. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2021;310:127606.

     

Journal of Ultrafine Grained and Nanostructured Materials
Volume 57, Issue 2
December 2024
Pages 203-221

  • Receive Date 17 July 2024
  • Revise Date 02 October 2024
  • Accept Date 03 October 2024